ASTL vs MSBI

Comparison between Algoma Steel Group Inc (ASTL, Company) and Midland States Bancorp Inc (MSBI, Company).

ASTL is from the Basic Materials sector, while MSBI is from the Financial Services sector.

5-Year PerformanceMSBI has outperformed ASTL, delivering a return of +6.1% compared to -15.4%

ASTL vs MSBI - Performance Comparison

Log

Key Characteristics

Financial metrics and valuation ratios

Metric	ASTL(COMPANY)	MSBI(COMPANY)
Market Cap	$579M	$579M
Max Drawdown	75.46%	65.76%
Sharpe Ratio	0.19	1.86
5Y Beta	1.51	0.79
Industry	Steel	Banks - Regional
P/E Ratio	-0.80	16.75
Forward P/E	7.01	8.22
PEG Ratio	-0.00	1.41
Dividend Yield	2.67%	4.45%
5Y Dividends CAGR	N/A	7.74%
5Y EPS CAGR	68.69%	-1.10%
Debt to Equity	0.00%	27.45%
Free Cash Flow Yield	-52.59%	19.66%
P/S Ratio	0.31	2.09
P/B Ratio	2.34	1.29

Market Cap

Winner

ASTL

$579M

MSBI

$579M

Max Drawdown

ASTL

75.46%

Winner

MSBI

65.76%

Sharpe Ratio

ASTL

0.19

Winner

MSBI

1.86

5Y Beta

ASTL

1.51

Winner

MSBI

0.79

Industry

ASTL

Steel

MSBI

Banks - Regional

P/E Ratio

Winner

ASTL

-0.80

MSBI

16.75

Forward P/E

Winner

ASTL

7.01

MSBI

8.22

PEG Ratio

Winner

ASTL

-0.00

MSBI

1.41

Dividend Yield

ASTL

2.67%

Winner

MSBI

4.45%

5Y Dividends CAGR

ASTL

N/A

MSBI

7.74%

5Y EPS CAGR

Winner

ASTL

68.69%

MSBI

-1.10%

Debt to Equity

Winner

ASTL

0.00%

MSBI

27.45%

Free Cash Flow Yield

ASTL

-52.59%

Winner

MSBI

19.66%

P/S Ratio

Winner

ASTL

0.31

MSBI

2.09

P/B Ratio

ASTL

2.34

Winner

MSBI

1.29

ASTL vs MSBI - Historical Returns

Returns include dividend reinvestment.

Period	ASTL	MSBI
1 month	+2.06%	+6.62%
3 months	+6.44%	+31.84%
6 months	+19.52%	+48.76%
1 year	-6.42%	+83.95%
5 years(CAGR)	-15.36%	+6.09%
10 years(CAGR)	N/A	+6.97%
Max(CAGR)	-15.36%	+7.44%

ASTL

+2.06%

Winner

MSBI

+6.62%

ASTL

+6.44%

Winner

MSBI

+31.84%

ASTL

+19.52%

Winner

MSBI

+48.76%

ASTL

-6.42%

Winner

MSBI

+83.95%

5Y(CAGR)

ASTL

-15.36%

Winner

MSBI

+6.09%

10Y(CAGR)

ASTL

N/A

MSBI

+6.97%

Max(CAGR)

ASTL

-15.36%

Winner

MSBI

+7.44%

ASTL vs MSBI - Annual Returns (2016 - 2026)

Returns include dividend reinvestment.

Year	ASTL	MSBI
2026	+26.53%	+38.03%
2025	-57.04%	-4.63%
2024	+5.00%	-6.84%
2023	+64.53%	+9.54%
2022	-38.45%	+9.65%
2021	-7.84%	+45.08%
2020	N/A	-34.19%
2019	N/A	+32.97%
2018	N/A	-29.19%
2017	N/A	-6.16%
2016	N/A	+67.58%

ASTL vs MSBI Drawdown Comparison

The maximum drawdown for ASTL was -73.16%, occurring on Oct 2, 2025. This drawdown has not yet recovered.

The maximum drawdown for MSBI was -61.18%, occurring on Sep 23, 2020. Recovery took 1376 trading sessions.

The current ASTL drawdown is -58.26%.

Rank	ASTL	MSBI
#1	-73.16% Nov 11, 2021 - Oct 2, 2025	-61.18% Jul 9, 2018 - Dec 26, 2023
#2	-9.36% Oct 25, 2021 - Nov 11, 2021	-44.33% Nov 6, 2024 - Apr 27, 2026
#3	-3.24% Oct 20, 2021 - Oct 25, 2021	-24.88% Dec 27, 2023 - Nov 6, 2024
#4	N/A	-19.19% Dec 28, 2016 - Jun 19, 2018
#5	N/A	-8.71% Dec 7, 2016 - Dec 20, 2016
#6	N/A	-8.20% Jun 6, 2016 - Aug 11, 2016
#7	N/A	-6.92% Oct 21, 2016 - Nov 10, 2016
#8	N/A	-5.89% May 7, 2026 - May 26, 2026
#9	N/A	-4.46% Jun 20, 2018 - Jul 9, 2018
#10	N/A	-3.90% Sep 9, 2016 - Sep 30, 2016
#11	N/A	-2.31% May 26, 2026 - Jun 4, 2026
#12	N/A	-2.11% Oct 5, 2016 - Oct 19, 2016
#13	N/A	-1.59% May 1, 2026 - May 5, 2026
#14	N/A	-1.57% Jun 2, 2016 - Jun 6, 2016
#15	N/A	-1.42% Apr 28, 2026 - Apr 30, 2026

Correlation

Correlation between ASTL and MSBI is 0.23 which considered as a very weak or no correlation - the stocks move independently of each other.

0.23

-101

Dividend Comparison (2016 - 2026)

ASTL vs MSBI dividend yield comparison.

Year	ASTL	MSBI
2026	0.00%	2.24%
2025	2.44%	5.95%
2024	2.04%	5.08%
2023	1.99%	4.35%
2022	3.15%	4.36%
2021	0.00%	4.52%
2020	0.00%	5.99%
2019	0.00%	3.35%
2018	0.00%	3.94%
2017	0.00%	2.46%
2016	0.00%	1.00%