AFG vs SAIA

Comparison between American Financial Group Inc (AFG, Company) and Saia Inc (SAIA, Company).

AFG is from the Financial Services sector, while SAIA is from the Industrials sector.

5-Year PerformanceSAIA has outperformed AFG, delivering a return of +15.2% compared to +10.8%

AFG vs SAIA - Performance Comparison

Log

Key Characteristics

Financial metrics and valuation ratios

Metric	AFG(COMPANY)	SAIA(COMPANY)
Market Cap	$11B	$11B
Max Drawdown	64.27%	80.35%
Sharpe Ratio	0.57	1.11
5Y Beta	0.43	1.44
Industry	Insurance - Property & Casualty	Trucking
P/E Ratio	13.10	44.75
Forward P/E	11.53	37.45
PEG Ratio	1.22	2.33
Dividend Yield	2.51%	N/A
5Y Dividends CAGR	-16.45%	N/A
5Y EPS CAGR	-8.90%	11.22%
Debt to Equity	38.91%	4.26%
Free Cash Flow Yield	14.50%	1.70%
P/S Ratio	1.45	3.50
P/B Ratio	2.46	4.34

Market Cap

Winner

AFG

$11B

SAIA

$11B

Max Drawdown

Winner

AFG

64.27%

SAIA

80.35%

Sharpe Ratio

AFG

0.57

Winner

SAIA

1.11

5Y Beta

Winner

AFG

0.43

SAIA

1.44

Industry

AFG

Insurance - Property & Casualty

SAIA

Trucking

P/E Ratio

Winner

AFG

13.10

SAIA

44.75

Forward P/E

Winner

AFG

11.53

SAIA

37.45

PEG Ratio

Winner

AFG

1.22

SAIA

2.33

Dividend Yield

AFG

2.51%

SAIA

N/A

5Y Dividends CAGR

AFG

-16.45%

SAIA

N/A

5Y EPS CAGR

AFG

-8.90%

Winner

SAIA

11.22%

Debt to Equity

AFG

38.91%

Winner

SAIA

4.26%

Free Cash Flow Yield

Winner

AFG

14.50%

SAIA

1.70%

P/S Ratio

Winner

AFG

1.45

SAIA

3.50

P/B Ratio

Winner

AFG

2.46

SAIA

4.34

AFG vs SAIA - Historical Returns

Returns include dividend reinvestment.

Period	AFG	SAIA
1 month	+2.75%	-7.99%
3 months	+8.90%	+27.83%
6 months	+3.49%	+30.06%
1 year	+18.12%	+59.01%
5 years(CAGR)	+10.80%	+15.23%
10 years(CAGR)	+15.54%	+33.62%
Max(CAGR)	+12.44%	+17.70%

Winner

AFG

+2.75%

SAIA

-7.99%

AFG

+8.90%

Winner

SAIA

+27.83%

AFG

+3.49%

Winner

SAIA

+30.06%

AFG

+18.12%

Winner

SAIA

+59.01%

5Y(CAGR)

AFG

+10.80%

Winner

SAIA

+15.23%

10Y(CAGR)

AFG

+15.54%

Winner

SAIA

+33.62%

Max(CAGR)

AFG

+12.44%

Winner

SAIA

+17.70%

AFG vs SAIA - Annual Returns (1999 - 2026)

Returns include dividend reinvestment.

Year	AFG	SAIA
2026	+6.08%	+27.68%
2025	+6.63%	-26.68%
2024	+23.21%	+6.60%
2023	-7.29%	+110.07%
2022	+12.38%	-33.39%
2021	+100.41%	+87.31%
2020	-17.32%	+92.77%
2019	+28.58%	+70.74%
2018	-11.62%	-21.93%
2017	+29.61%	+57.57%
2016	+28.46%	+102.62%
2015	+23.23%	-60.06%
2014	+11.05%	+81.39%
2013	+49.47%	+104.14%
2012	+8.30%	+76.09%
2011	+14.20%	-25.36%
2010	+29.55%	+15.45%
2009	+9.06%	+31.73%
2008	-18.23%	-14.82%
2007	-19.89%	-43.95%
2006	+42.58%	+4.08%
2005	+25.44%	-7.29%
2004	+20.43%	+34.62%
2003	+16.50%	+73.03%
2002	-1.88%	-25.93%
2001	-3.80%	N/A
2000	+9.32%	N/A
1999	-8.43%	N/A

AFG vs SAIA Drawdown Comparison

The maximum drawdown for AFG was -62.93%, occurring on Mar 9, 2009. Recovery took 999 trading sessions.

The maximum drawdown for SAIA was -80.35%, occurring on Nov 20, 2008. Recovery took 1612 trading sessions.

The current AFG drawdown is -1.84%. The current SAIA drawdown is -28.95%.

Rank	AFG	SAIA
#1	-62.93% Feb 21, 2007 - Feb 7, 2011	-80.35% Oct 16, 2006 - Mar 14, 2013
#2	-58.98% Feb 11, 2020 - Feb 22, 2021	-65.82% Dec 4, 2014 - Aug 31, 2017
#3	-38.10% Apr 19, 2002 - Feb 2, 2004	-60.94% Mar 6, 2024 - Apr 29, 2025
#4	-38.06% Jul 13, 2001 - Apr 17, 2002	-53.15% Nov 17, 2021 - Jul 17, 2023
#5	-37.71% Nov 5, 1999 - Feb 5, 2001	-49.18% Sep 12, 2002 - Jul 2, 2003
#6	-26.46% Feb 1, 2018 - Nov 27, 2019	-44.51% Jun 23, 2004 - Jan 25, 2006
#7	-23.79% Nov 10, 2022 - Mar 25, 2024	-39.57% Jun 12, 2018 - Sep 4, 2019
#8	-22.41% Feb 5, 2001 - Jun 11, 2001	-39.00% Oct 28, 2019 - May 26, 2020
#9	-19.87% Nov 25, 2024 - Sep 24, 2025	-24.09% Mar 15, 2006 - Aug 16, 2006
#10	-16.15% Jun 7, 2022 - Oct 28, 2022	-21.51% Sep 1, 2023 - Dec 21, 2023
#11	-16.07% Jul 7, 2011 - Oct 24, 2011	-21.10% May 7, 2021 - Aug 11, 2021
#12	-13.18% Oct 3, 2025 - Mar 20, 2026	-19.00% Sep 22, 2003 - Dec 2, 2003
#13	-12.24% Nov 16, 2004 - May 4, 2005	-18.30% Jul 11, 2013 - Oct 22, 2013
#14	-12.05% Mar 27, 2024 - Sep 9, 2024	-17.02% Jan 25, 2018 - May 21, 2018
#15	-11.76% Dec 4, 2015 - Jun 23, 2016	-14.17% Oct 22, 2013 - Mar 4, 2014